蜜桃传媒破解版下载

Skip to main content

Is beauty about looks鈥攐r views?

Screenshots from YouTube showing a collection of stills of young Asian American women before and after their makeup transformations.

The Asian baby girl trend鈥攕ocial media videos in which young Asian American women transform themselves with makeup, hair treatments, glasses, temporary tattoos and more鈥攊s all over social media. Researcher Seonah Kim says the trend tells us a lot about commodification and shifting dynamics of cultural representation online. Clockwise from top left, photos courtesy @maiphammy, @MishChoi, @stephaniewose, @RoxetteArisa, @ohnonina and @Lolwutjan via YouTube.

Let鈥檚 get your first question out of the way: Seonah Kim is not interested in makeup.

鈥淚鈥檓 like a film scholar who likes studying cinema more than watching movies,鈥 Kim said. 鈥淚鈥檓 not into beauty, but I enjoy studying it鈥攕pecifically, how Asian women鈥檚 bodies are racialized and gendered in media through beauty.鈥

Asian culture is enjoying a moment on screens and in streams across the United States, from Squid Game and Beef to K-pop. But most of Kim鈥檚 research looks at so-called 鈥淎sian baby girl鈥 videos on YouTube, in which young Asian Americans dramatically transform their appearance with makeup, temporary tattoos, hair treatments and more. 听

Kim, an assistant teaching professor of media studies at 蜜桃传媒破解版下载 College of Communication, Media, Design and Information, began studying the Asian baby girl phenomenon as a part of a book project. But the real origin story of this research comes from interviews she did with South Korean women who darkened their skin as part of their beauty regime. Kim sought to understand why they did so when many of their contemporaries focused on making their skin lighter.

鈥淭hey would tell me, 鈥業 know I cannot be Caucasian, but this is a way to experiment with a kind of American identity,鈥欌 Kim said. 听

Headshot of Seonah Kim

Seonah Kim

She was especially interested in South Korean women who darkened their skin as part of their beauty regime.

In her extensive interviews with Korean women who darken their skin, Kim found a rebellious streak鈥攑eople challenging the 鈥渕odel minority鈥 stereotype and looking to stand out from the crowd. Many told Kim they chose to darken themselves to resist the narrative of people who want to be lighter.

That helped lead her to Asian Americans performing the Asian baby girl identity. In those videos, she saw influencers adopting a rebellious streak of Asian Americans from a generation ago, who challenged the 鈥渕odel minority鈥 stereotype to stand out from the crowd.

Shifting dynamics on social

Now, with digital and social media, these transformations are a powerful source for attention. Just look at the virality of Asian baby girl videos, as Kim does.

鈥淥n social media, we see the commodification of an aesthetic that has a lot of historical context,鈥 Kim said. 鈥淭his idea of beauty was created by a few Asian American women who wanted to challenge deep-seated stereotypes in the United States. When the Asian baby girl becomes ahistorical, visually appealing and easily consumable, it tells us quite a bit about the shifting dynamics of cultural representation and the self-commodification of Asian American identity in digital media.鈥

The result of ABG videos鈥攁nd heightened Asian visibility in current media鈥攊s a positive sign to Kim, though it鈥檚 not without its drawbacks.

鈥淲e鈥檙e seeing different types of Asian Americans鈥攖hey鈥檙e outspoken, funny, angry, entertaining. But at the same time, we risk trading one set of tropes for another.鈥

Seonah Kim, assistant teaching professor

鈥淲e鈥檙e seeing different types of Asian Americans鈥攖hey鈥檙e outspoken, funny, angry, entertaining,鈥 she said. 鈥淏ut at the same time, we risk trading one set of tropes for another. I鈥檓 not saying whether it鈥檚 good or bad, just that we need to be more critical of the media we see and the story it鈥檚 telling.鈥

In , Kim explored how YouTube鈥檚 attention economy has commodified Asian femininity. Though Asian Americans of a generation ago used beauty as a way to express independence and establish a counterculture, creators on social media don鈥檛 have that same influence over Western media.

鈥淭ikTok and Instagram reward content that鈥檚 visually entertaining and sexualized,鈥 she said, 鈥渁nd unfortunately, I don鈥檛 see the digital space encouraging those types of discourses.鈥

It鈥檚 a topic she gets to explore in some depth in her classes, as well. Kim teaches an introductory social media course, as well as classes in media literacy and digital culture, where students can observe the impact of the attention economy on culture. The questions she gets there, Kim said, tend to focus on the media panic being generated around digital platforms and artificial intelligence.

鈥淭hey really want to understand how social media works, to better evaluate that panic narrative,鈥 she said. 鈥淭hey want to be better consumers of media.鈥

Her focus on commodification in ABG videos can be read as negative, but Kim said she appreciates the Asian American creators trying to carve out their own cultural niche in the digital media landscape, and who are producing different narratives about representation.

It鈥檚 a consideration she鈥檚 keeping in mind as she continues to study themes around representational inequality in transnational contexts. She鈥檚 especially keen on the idea of how the performance of ABG can challenge what it means to be seen as American. In fact, Kim is now at work on a book project incorporating her work on skin darkening among Korean women and the ways these women embrace and perform 鈥淎mericanness鈥 through the Asian baby girl phenomenon鈥攁long with how those practices challenge racial constructs in Asian contexts.

鈥淯ntil now, from an Asian standpoint, Americanness is closely tied to the representation of whiteness,鈥 she said. 鈥淐ould that be replaced with a more Asian American representation鈥攁nd what are the risks in doing so?鈥


Joe Arney covers research and general news for the college.